Messaging

The Explanation Tax

By Joe Franklin, Brand Strategist

4 min read

The Explanation Tax is the cost a company pays every time its brand needs explaining. It shows up as longer sales calls, pitch decks that need a narrator, and prospects who nod politely and never call back.

I’m Joe Franklin, a brand strategist, and I started calling it that in 2026 after years of watching good companies pay it without ever seeing it. Nobody sends you a bill, so it’s easy to miss. It shows up as buyers who stay confused and walk away, and as companies forced to compete on features, and then on price.

Where you pay it

  • In sales. Your team spends the first 10 minutes of every call explaining what you do before they can get to why it matters.

  • In fundraising. An investor reads your deck and still asks, “So what exactly do you do?” (A deck that needs a voiceover has a tax problem.)

  • In hiring. Good candidates can’t tell their friends what they’d be working on.

  • In word of mouth. Happy customers want to recommend you but can’t find the words, so they don’t.

  • In marketing. Every campaign has to re-explain the basics, so less of the budget goes to the actual message.

  • In AI search. This is the newer one, a second bill on top of the first. AI tools repeat what they see said consistently, so if your website, your execs and your sales team each describe the company a little differently, the answer a buyer gets back from ChatGPT will be blurry too. It can only work with what you’ve given it.

How to tell if you’re paying it

Here’s a quick test. Show your homepage to someone outside your industry for 10 seconds, then ask them three questions: What does this company do? Who’s it for? Why would someone pick it over the alternatives? If they hesitate on any of the three, you’re paying.

A few other signs I see often:

  • Your execs each describe the company in their own way.

  • Your sales team has quietly rewritten the official deck.

  • You compete on features and price because nobody understands what makes you different.

  • You lose deals to companies with a weaker product and a simpler story.

Why it happens

Usually for good reasons. The product evolved faster than the story. The company added a second audience. A pivot happened and the website kept the old language. Or the team describes the company the way insiders see it, through features, technology and roadmap, while the buyer is still trying to understand what problem it solves.

Inside the company the story makes perfect sense, which is exactly why it’s hard to spot. (It’s tough to read the label from inside the jar.)

What it costs

The Explanation Tax is rarely a line item, which is how it survives every budget review. You see it in longer sales cycles, fewer first calls turning into second calls, discounts to get deals over the line, and marketing that has to work harder than it should. It also compounds: every new hire, campaign and market inherits the same unclear story.

How to lower it

The fix starts with positioning, before any design work. Three questions do most of the heavy lifting:

  1. What category do buyers put you in, and is that the one you want to be in?

  2. What can you do that the alternatives can’t, in words a buyer would actually use?

  3. Who’s it for? And just as important, who isn’t it for?

Then agree on one clear sentence about what you do and who it’s for, and say it the same way everywhere: the website, the deck, the sales calls, your LinkedIn profiles. Once that’s settled, the message, the website and the visual identity finally have something to express. Changing the logo first mostly gives the tax a fresh coat of paint.

How I measure it

The Brand Truth Assessment is how I find out what a company’s Explanation Tax is and where it comes from. For you it takes about an hour: a questionnaire about your company, your buyers and your competitors. I do the research and send a written report within 10 business days, then we walk through it together on a one-hour call. You’ll know what to fix first, and whether you need a rebrand at all.

Joe Franklin · Brand Strategist · San Juan, Puerto Rico

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

© 2026 Joe Franklin

Brand strategy and transformation for companies at inflection points.

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

© 2026 Joe Franklin

Brand strategy and transformation for companies at inflection points.

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

  • JOE FRANKLIN

  • -

© 2026 Joe Franklin

Brand strategy and transformation for companies at inflection points.